HDPE Pipe as a Solution to Utilities Operating on a Manage to Fail Basis

Papers # 2018 Las-Vegas

Many cities in the US are operating their water utility on a “manage to fail” basis, meaning they are replacing >100-year-old pipes at a cycle time of over 150 years. At this rate, most of the pipes will have failed before they can be replaced. Ft. Wayne, IN made the realization that PE pipe is the solution due to its durability and longevity. There has been extensive testing on why HDPE pipe is durable and there are standards and tests to ensure that it can last over 100 years in the ground.

Many municipalities treat their systems on a manage-to-fail basis. Replacement schedules are drawn out to where failures and leaks steadily increase over time placing a burden on water operations. Maintenance dollars and repair dollars could be used for capital improvement, but they are not because the needs for repair grow over time. Water system operations in Fraser, MI, the Oroville Dam, Los Angeles, San Antonio Water System, Louisville, KY, and the City of Philadelphia are used as examples to describe this “manage to fail” practice. 

The Oroville Dam failure resulted in the evacuation of 188,000 people and an $850 million fix. The state was warned to go beyond a visual inspection as cracks were visible on the dam given the cracks had been found repeatedly since 2009. This dam was managed to the point of failure.

Fraser, MI bought a wastewater interceptor line from another utility with a known history of costly failures. In 2016, a sinkhole formed as a result of the failed large diameter sewage line. This failure affected sewage operations for 500,000 residents in 11 communities. The cost of rehab would have been $6 - $8 million had it been dealt with properly, but it turned out to be a $150 million repair bill. 

Ft. Wayne, IN made the decision to rehab with HDPE due to the drastically increasing amount of water main breaks in their system. Since then, they’ve seen a steady decrease in main breaks. Utilities should consider the Ft. Wayne best practice model.

It is important to note that HDPE use has a positive effect on water treatment capacity, lowers electricity cost, and positively affects the social costs of roads that are undermined by water leaks. Water loss has been proven to be significantly reduced and water quality is preserved.

Related keywords : HDPE, rehabilitation, cost, water, cases.
Please note that the whole article content is available on PPCA website onlySource : 2018 Las-Vegas


Related papers

A RECENT SURVEY OF WATER MAIN FAILURES IN THE US AND CANADA

Author(s) : Steven Folkman 2018 Las-Vegas

A recent survey again confirms that PVC pipe has the lowest break rate when compared with break rates of ductile and cast iron, asbestos cement, steel, and concrete pipe. Other results of interest to water utilities and engineers are discussed. During 2017, Utah State University conducted a survey of utilities across...

CHLORINE DIOXIDE RESISTANT HDPE MECHANISM, ANALYTICAL TOOLS AND SOLUTIONS

Author(s) : M. Boerakker, S. van Mierloo, D. v. Beek, R. Schipper, P. Voets, M. Soliman, K. Jacobson, D. Lukes, B. Rabaud, F. Zraick 2018 Las-Vegas

HDPE pipes are used for standard pressurized water pipes, offering an excellent solution for safe transport of (drinking) water. The HDPE pipe market is growing globally. Especially in countries that suffer from water scarcity, surface water and water from rivers have to be used for drinking water supply. To guarantee...

DISCOVER: PLASTICS

Author(s) : Davidovski Zoran 2018 Las-Vegas

To get a deeper insight in why plastic pipes systems in some cases are deselected by designers, installers and users, European Plastics Pipes and Fittings Association (TEPPFA) initiated a research including interviews in four pilot countries: Poland, France, Germany and the UK. The first phase was concentrating on...

EFFECT OF BETA-NUCLEATION ON AGING AND CRACK GROWTH RESISTANCE OF POLYPROPYLENE EXPOSED TO CHLORINATED WATER

Author(s) : Joerg Fischer, Paul J. Freudenthaler, Patrick R. Bradler, Reinhold W. Lang, Susan C. Mantell 2018 Las-Vegas

This research addresses the effect of nucleation on the global aging behavior and the fatigue crack growth (FCG) resistance of commercial alpha- and beta-nucleated polypropylene random copolymer pipe grades (PP-R) when exposed to chlorinated water (5 mg/l free chlorine) at an elevated temperature of 60°C. Comparing...

FATIGUE CRACK GROWTH TESTING IN CHLORINATED WATER AT ELEVATED TEMPERATURES - TEST EQUIPMENT AND TEST PROCEDURE

Author(s) : Joerg Fischer, Patrick R. Bradler, Reinhold W. Lang 2018 Las-Vegas

In the present paper, a novel test system for conducting fatigue crack growth (FCG) experiments under superimposed mechanical-environmental conditions is presented. FCG experiments were performed on a polypropylene (PP) grade and a short-glass fiber reinforced polyamide 66 (PA-GF) grade as model materials. The...

GUIDELINES FOR CORRUGATED HDPE PIPES MANUFACTURED WITH RECYCLED MATERIALS FOR HIGHWAY CULVERT AND STORM DRAIN APPLICATIONS

Author(s) : Michael Pluimer, Richard Thomas 2018 Las-Vegas

Over the past decade, there have been several key research projects to evaluate the performance of corrugated HDPE pipes manufactured with post-consumer and postindustrial recycled materials for highway and railroad drainage applications. Three of these projects were recently completed and published (NCHRP Project...

HARMONIZING THE EUROPEAN HYGIENIC REQUIREMENTS

Author(s) : Ilari Aho, Volker Meyer, Peter Sejersen 2018 Las-Vegas

The lack of a cross-border acceptance of the approval of the hygienic requirements for plastic pipes systems is inefficient and expensive for the industry. The costs for testing of a pipe system range from a few thousand Euro to more than €30k /reference 3, 4/. The European Plastic Pipe and Fitting Association...

HIGH DENSITY POLYETHYLENE (HDPE): AN OVERVIEW OF THE FIRST EVER ASME BPVC SECTION III, CLASS 3 NUCLEAR PIPING INSTALLATION

Author(s) : Ali Al Hammadi, Shane R. Schuessler, Mohamed Ali Awadh Jaber 2018 Las-Vegas

This paper presents the advancements of HDPE piping materials, design and installation for use in ASME Class 3 piping systems at nuclear power plants. The paper will specifically introduce details of the first ever ASME Class III nuclear new build use of Class 3 HDPE pipe and fittings at the Emirates Nuclear Energy...

HIGH MODULUS PP TANKS DELIVERS PRACTICAL & COST EFFECTIVE SEWAGE TREATMENT TO RURAL INDONESIA

Author(s) : Marc van Loo (Dr.), Constant Van Aerschot, KumHoong Lou 2018 Las-Vegas

In many parts of rural developing Asia and even some parts of Africa, sewerage from households is often discharged directly to the surrounding. This unfortunate fact means that many waterborne diseases such as cholera, dysentery and typhoid continue to afflict these communities. Numerous efforts from governments,...

NEW DISCOVERIES IN STABILIZING DRINKING WATER PIPES IN CONTACT WITH CHLORINE DIOXIDE

Author(s) : J.D. Kim, S. Kim , T. Schmutz, C. Malchaire, D. Scholz, K. Keck 2018 Las-Vegas

Since a few years, pipe producers are facing the challenge to protect their plastic pipe from degradation due to chlorine dioxide. Unfortunately, most existing stabilization solutions are not effective enough to insure the desired lifetime of the material. This study shows how the latest development allow to top-up...

PANORAMIC VIEW OF A WATER MAIN REPLACEMENT PROJECT IN A FIRE-SEISMIC GEOHAZARD ZONE

Author(s) : K. Moita 2018 Las-Vegas

East Bay Municipal Utility District (District) provides water and wastewater services to the eastern region of the San Francisco Bay Area in California. The District’s potable water system serves approximately 1.4 million customers in a 332-square-mile area that spans portions of Alameda and Contra Costa Counties....

PE100 LARGE DIAMETER WATER TRANSMISSION PIPELINES TAKE OFF IN ASIA

Author(s) : Andrew Wedgner, Muhammad Qasim, Arsenio Sembrano 2018 Las-Vegas

Developments in material and pipe extrusion technology now enable converters to produce PE100 solid wall pipes of up to 2,800mm OD, but the use of such large diameters has been limited to industrial applications. This is now starting to change with water transmission pipelines of up to 1400mm OD being laid in the UAE...

PERFORMANCE OF LARGE MARINE HDPE PIPES DURING THE SUBMERSION AS BASED ON LABORATORY TESTING

Author(s) : Ilija Radeljic, Ingemar Björklund 2018 Las-Vegas

Installations of solid wall HDPE pipes are becoming more difficult and riskier with the increase in diameter (OD2000+ mm), length of strings (1000+ meters) and reduction in the wall thickness (SDR26-30). To gain a better understanding of the limits of the final pipe assembly prior to the sinking, a laboratory tests in...

PRODUCT ENVIRONMENTAL FOOTPRINT (PEF) METHOD COMPARED WITH ENVIRONMENTAL PRODUCT DECLARATIONS (EPDS)

Author(s) : Ludo Debever, Peter Sejersen, Carolin Spirinckx 2018 Las-Vegas

Until today there are various ways of demonstrating the Environmental Performance of products, such as Life Cycle Assessments (LCA), Life Cycle Impact Assessments (LCIA), Environmental Performance Declarations (EPDs). The methods to obtain the result, however, can vary from country to country and can be interpreted...

Production of Potable Water Pipes for Chile Using the Inline Extrusion Process

Author(s) : Douglas D. Keller 2018 Las-Vegas

This paper describes the successful collaboration of a regulator, pipe producer and PE material supplier to demonstrate the conformance of pipes produced with inline extrusion compound to the requirement of the Chilean water pipe normative NCh398/1.Of2004 and also to the performance requirements of ISO 4427:2007 parts...

REHABILITATION OF ABANDONED DN1000MM STEEL PIPE WITH PE100 IN MALAYSIA

Author(s) : KianLin Ng, WengKeong Tan, KumHoong Lou 2018 Las-Vegas

Heavy and constant trucked container traffic combined with an accelerated ground settlement in a coastal reclaimed land caused a DN1000mm cement-lined mild steel water pipeline that crossed under it to sink by more than 6m from its original buried depth. This then caused the internal & external cement lining to...

STUDY ON PARAMETERS AFFECTING DURABILITY OF POLYETHYLENE PIPES FOR HOT WATER APPLICATION

Author(s) : Hirofumi Kyutoku, Kazuhisa Igawa, Hidekazu Honma, Sakiko Fukunishi, Hiroyuki Nishimura 2018 Las-Vegas

There are mainly two grades of polyethylene pipes for hot water supply and heating. The excellent molecular structure polyethylene resins having resistance to stress crack growth are used because hot water is flowed for a long time in both polyethylene pipes. Furthermore, various additives are mixed to prevent the...

VARIABILITY AND QUALITY CONTROL FOR PRODUCTION OF CORRUGATED HDPE PIPE MANUFACTURED WITH RECYCLED CONTENT

Author(s) : Crista K. McNish, Joe Babcanec, Rachel M. Thurston, Zacharias Obermeyer 2018 Las-Vegas

This paper presents findings from extensive testing performed on various recycled HDPE resins at different stages of processing to evaluate: (1) the variability expected from a source resin (e.g. post-consumer materials from bulk recycling, post-industrial waste stream), (2) variability when blending different types...

ADVANCED APPLICATIONS FOR HDPE PIPES WITH NEW PE-RT MATERIAL

Author(s) : Wes Long, Carl F. Baker 2016 Berlin

Canfor’s Prince George Pulp & Paper Mill in Prince George, BC, Canada operates a bleach plant effluent system for the production of Bleached Kraft Pulp. The original underground fiberglass reinforced pipe (FRP) presents an elevated risk to both environment and production targets. Over the past five years there...

COMPARISON BETWEEN STRESS RUPTURE TEST AND HOT WATER CIRCULATION TEST CONSIDERING ACTUAL OPERATING CONDITION OF PE PIPES FOR HOT WATER APPLICATION

Author(s) : Takehiro Fujii, Kazuhisa Igawa, Hidekazu Honma, Kazushi Yamada, Hiroyuki Nishimura 2016 Berlin

The hydrostatic stress rupture test has been conventionally conducted as a good method of the lifetime evaluation. The hot water circulation test which is reflected to the actual operating condition is also useful method. The correlations and differences between the two tests were examined. Compared with the...

Members of the Association

BOREALISBOROUGEINEOS O&PIRPCKorea Petrochemical IND. Co., LTDLyondellBasellPetroChina Dushanzi Petrochemical CompanyPRIME POLYMERSABICSCG Chemicals & Thai PolyethyleneSinopecTASNEE
TOP