Papers
Plastic Pipes Conference Association # 2014 Chicago
Andreas Frank, Isabelle J. Berger, Florian Arbeiter, Gerald Pinter
During the past years the Cyclic Cracked Round Bar (CRB) Test has been developed and meanwhile standardized as a new and modern test method for a quick material ranking of polyethylene pipe grades by their resistance against slow crack growth (SCG). As an additional benefit this test method allows a very precise determination of crack initiation which provides further lifetime relevant information of the material. The objective of the current paper is a demonstration of the practical application of the Cyclic CRB Test for a quick material ranking. On the one hand, the study of the crack initiation and SCG behavior of ten PE 100 and PE 100-RC pipe grades from five different raw material supplier demonstrate that there are significant differences in the material performance, even within one material class. On the other hand, based on the failure curves of 35 different PE pipe grades the results show that, at least at room temperature, the performance of PE 100 and PE 100-RC has an overlap.
Pressurized pipes of polyethylene (PE) used for gas and water applications are designed to fulfill operating times of at least 50 years [1-6]. As a result of developments and improvements of the raw materials, particularly in the bimodal molecular mass distribution and in the controlled implementation of short chain branches, an increase in minimum service expected [5]. The classification of PE pipe grades is based on the long-term failure behavior of internal pipe pressure tests at different temperatures and extrapolation methods as described in EN ISO 9080 [7] or ASTM D2837 [8]. The long-term failure mechanisms of pressurized PE pipes have been studied comprehensively and are well known as crack initiation and quasi-brittle slow crack growth (SCG) [2, 3, 9-11]. Internal pipe pressure tests on PE pipe grades typically last several months or even years. In practice testing of pipes that do not fail after duration of 104 hours (approx. 13.5 months) are usually stopped. Based on such tests the minimum required strength (MRS) to ensure pipe lifetimes of at least 50 years is determined and leads to a classification of the materials as PE 63 (MRS=6,3 MPa), PE 80 (MRS=8 MPa) or PE 100 (MRS=10 MPa). For PE 100 which also pass the requirements according PAS 1075 [12] an additional classification PE 100-RC (RC=Resistant to Crack) has been defined.
The appreciated material improvements of the raw material suppliers have increased the failure times of internal pipe pressure tests significantly resulting in time consuming and expensive test procedures. Especially for modern grades of the classification PE 100 and PE 100-RC no quantitative information about the relevant quasi-brittle failure region can be determined with internal pipe pressure tests anymore. To meet the demand for an accelerated material characterization and to rank different materials by their SCG resistance, several laboratory tests like the Notched Pipe Test (NPT) [13-15], the Pennsylvania Edge-Notch Test (PENT) [16-18], the Notched Ring Test (NRT) [19] or the Full Notch Creep Test (FNCT) [20-22] have been developed. All this test methods are usually conducted at elevated temperatures of T=80 °C or even under the influence of stress cracking liquids (FNCT). Although the mentioned tests provide a significant acceleration of testing times, characterization of modern PE pipe grades is still related to long testing times of several months up to years. According to further time reduction in the characterization of SCG properties, recent studies have shown promising results 2 Copyright © 2014 by PPCA for two new test methods, the Strain Hardening Modulus [23-26] and the Cyclic Cracked Round Bar (CRB) Test [27-47] which has been recently standardized by the Austrian Standards Institute in ONR 25194 [48].
The current paper investigates ten PE 100 and PE 100-RC pipe grades from five different raw material supplier which are currently available in the market with the Cyclic CRB Test. On the one hand, the results demonstrate the practical application of the Cyclic CRB Test for a quick material ranking by the crack resistance of the materials. On the other hand, the additional information about crack initiation also allows a more detailed investigation of the materials. Moreover, based on Cyclic CRB Tests of 35 different PE pipe grades in the laboratory of the authors the generated data demonstrate that different failure ranges are determined depending on the PE classification and that, at least at room temperature, the failure performance of PE 100 and PE 100-RC has an overlap.
Related papers
Author(s) : A. Taraiya, P. Degenhart, M. Soliman, M. Boerakker, R. Handstanger, R. Kleppinger
Since the introduction of polyolefins for pressure pipes, continuous improvements have been made to meet ever-higher demands on their performance and to expand their application window beyond their original scope, mostly based on new resin formulations. Today, we also continue to push the limit to provide better...
Author(s) : Paul J. Freudenthaler, Joerg Fischer, Mathias Eder, Reinhold W. Lang
For controlled water disinfection, typically chlorine is used and preliminary studies demonstrate its aging and crack growth acceleration effects on polyolefin pipe materials [1, 2]. Although the use of recycled plastics is not prohibited in some ISO standards for polyolefin piping systems [3–5], only small amounts...
Author(s) : Shuhei Nishida, Shintaro Iwasaki, Hidefumi Yamanaka, Takahiro Kasatani
Polyethylene pipelines have been used for natural gas service applications for over 40 years in Japan. It is thought that they will continue to be used widely for many years. Therefore, it is important to confirm the conditions of the existing pipelines being used for the long term. In this study, polyethylene pipes...
Author(s) : James F. Mason, Akshay Ponda, Hermann van Laak, Buc Slay
The effects of liquid hydrocarbons on long term strength of pipe grade thermoplastic resins is an important consideration when designing pressure pipe for use in the oil and gas industry. There is an extensive body of work going back several decades descri bing these effects for pipe grade polyethylenes, and all...
Author(s) : Ernst van der Stok
For PE 100-RC, two tests are still under development for pipes: the point load test (PLT) and the accelerated notch pipe test (aNPT). The PLT was developed by a project group consisting of manufacturers and end users. The PLT determines the resistance to point loads as they can occur in practice. An earlier study...
Author(s) : S. Nestelberger, J. Cheng
The Point Load Test (PLT) [ 1, 2] was designed to simulate the SCG (slow crack growth) failure initiated by a rock pressing into the exterior wall of a polymer pipe. Today’s PE materials sustain long PLT testing times, due to its high SCG resistance design. Consequently, an accelerated “PLT+” with the support of...
Author(s) : Dr. Holger Brüning, Serge Hascoët, Yann Delanne, Didier Nozahic, Jawdat Mansour, José Santana
RTE operates, maintains and develops the French electricity network, including the High and very High Voltage cable lines. Their network is the largest in Europe and includes over 6400 km of underground HV links operated in 2018. The company is modernizing and developing its network by investing 1.5 billion euros per...
Author(s) : Gerald Pinter, Johannes Wiener, Florian Arbeiter, Abhishek Tiwari, Otmar Kolednik
For pipe applications, catastrophic failure due to crack growth has to be prevented by all means. Techniques to develop new and even tougher pipe materials are explored in this contribution. The aim is to create a multi-layer architecture, that exhibits high toughness as well as damage tolerance towards sharp notches....
Author(s) : Sultan Alkendi, Mohamed Jaber, Ahmed Atef Helal
The current push to reduce governmental energy subsidies has moved the need to adapt utility gas distribution networks toward the top of Middle Eastern governmental near-term agendas. Egypt is at the forefront of this push towards gasification. The United Arab Emirates has started on the path towards gasification...
Author(s) : Mario Messiha, Britta Gerets, Jan Heimink, Andreas Frank, Florian Arbeiter, Gerald Pinter
A majority of field failure of viscoelastic plastic pipes can be attributed to slow crack growth (SCG) and has become crucial in terms of characterization of newly developed materials – particularly, if they are designed for pressurized pipe applications. In this study, investigations in terms of SCG resistances...
Author(s) : Lukas Travnicek, Pavel Hutar, Jan Poduska, Andreas Frank, Florian Arbeiter, Jaroslav Kucera, Jiri Sadilek, Gerald Pinter, Lubos Nahlik
The application of recycled material in pressure piping systems has been considered lately – it was suggested, that the recycled polyethylene could be used as a part of a multilayer pipe together with virgin material. This type of pressure pipes is not availableon the market yet, so their properties can be only...
Author(s) : Yoshikatsu NISHIDA, Yukihisa YAMADA, Masaya IWASAKI, Masaru TOMOBE, Yuichi KOUGA
By using polyethylene as the main material for this fire extinguishing device pipe, a resin-made fire extinguishing device is developed that is maintenance-free for eight years and can cope with the abnormal heat generation of lithium ion batteries. In order to prevent the internal extinguishant from permeating and...
Author(s) : Justin Brandt, Mike Griffin, Tony Cuvo
As plastic pipe gains share in new markets and applications, additional joining methods add further value, enabling continued growth for plastic pipes. To date, definitions of a “fit-for-purpose” mechanical joint for High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) pressure piping systems can vary significantly. As such, mechanical...
Author(s) : Mark Boerakker, Rudy Deblieck, a Harm Caelers, Arno Wilbers, Tine Boonen a DSM, Britta Gerets, Mirko Wenzel
Components made of plastic are facing ever-increasing demands with respect to their production, use and durability. This also holds for gas and drinking water pressure pipes made of high-density polyethylene (PE-HD), where service lifetimes of up to 50 years and in some cases even 100 years are required. One of the...
Author(s) : Andreas Frank, Mario Messiha, Günter Dreiling, Norbert Schuler, Jens-Martin Storheil, Erwin Mayrbäurl, Stuart Ramella, Frank Krause, Rudi Berning, Philippe Gabriëls, Alpay Aydemir, Thomas Koch, Florian Arbeiter, Gerald Pinter
The Cyclic Cracked Round Bar (CRB) Test has been applied to study the slow crack growth (SCG) resistance of virgin, recycled, and reprocessed PVC-U. This fracture mechanical test allows a quick ranking of the SCG resistance of PVC-U. A clear correlation between the K-value and the SCG resistance has been elaborated....
Author(s) : Dr. Stefan Fokken
NGO pressure and end of life disposal of PVC articles in the EU over 30 years ago, triggered intense discussion about the sustainable use of PVC and its additives. Stabiliser producers and downstream users of PVC stabiliser compounds base upon Lead and Cadmium based stabilisers have developed solutions ultimately...
Author(s) : Sjoerd Jansma, Peter Cloos, Ernst van der Stok
This paper describes two different test methods used to determine the permeation rate of hydrogen through a reinforced thermoplastic pipe (RTP) system with a HDPE liner pipe and a gas-tight layer at a pressure of 42 bar(g) hydrogen and ambient temperature. One method involThe results of the aforementioned tests...
Author(s) : Britta Gerets, Mirko Wenzel, Kurt Engelsing
The strain hardening test (SHT, ISO 18488 [1]) becomes increasingly important for the characterization of high-density polyethylene (HDPE) grades and pipes made thereof. With regard to small pipe diameters, a smaller test specimen than the one defined in ISO 18488 has been developed. SHT results were demonstrated to...
Author(s) : Hermann van Laak, Jan Heimink, Mario Messiha, Andreas Frank, Christoph Bruckner, Thomas Kratochvilla
For high pressure pipes above maximum operation pressure of 10 bar, this paper emphasizes PA-U12 as the easy to install alternative to steel. It underlines the superb performance of PA-U12 pipes for alternative installation techniques without need for a separate mechanical protection. An unplasticized polyamide 12...
Author(s) : Thomas R. Kratochvilla, Raimund Eremiasch, Christoph Bruckner
In the last years effort has been made to develop and standardise new accelerated test methods to evaluate PE 100-RC materials in short times in form of test bars. The two most important developments, the cracked round bar test (CRB test) and the strain hardening test (SH test) were published as final ISO standards in...
Members of the Association
