ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA FOR VOLUME DEFECTS IN WELDED ASSEMBLIES, DETECTED AND SIZED USING THE PHASED ARRAY ULTRASONIC TECHNIQUE

Papers # 2018 Las-Vegas

Given the virtual absence of available up-to-date results regarding the acceptance criteria for defects at electro-welding interfaces, a study has been launched by GRTgaz RICE with the two-fold aim of confirming the accuracy of the PAUT technique for the detection and sizing of calibrated pit-shaped defects implanted in an electrofusion(EF) tapping saddle on the one hand, and of evaluating the harmfulness of these volume defects on the mechanical strength of a pipe-saddle EF assembly through hydrostatic pressure testing, on the other hand. This study reveals the good reliability level of PAUT in detecting and sizing the volume defects - even the smallest ones - implanted in the saddles on the one hand, and the fair correlation existing between PAUT and X-Ray Tomography as a complementary technique on the other hand. The hydrostatic pressure tests do not reveal any detrimental influence of the defects – in terms of both location and size - on the mechanical resistance of the welded assemblies in these laboratory conditions. At this stage, pending complementary investigations, no correlation can be established between the observed failure times and the position and size of the volume defects implanted in the tapping saddles.

Phased Array Ultrasonic Technique (PAUT) is currently recognised as the reference technique for non-destructive evaluation of electrowelded assemblies. Therefore, over the past five years, CRIGEN has managed a research pogram comprising various test campaigns both on assemblies recovered from the field and on lab specimens. The primary aim of these campaigns was to evaluate the accuracy of the technique, on the one hand in terms of the detectability of defects mainly located at the pipe-fitting interface and, on the other hand, in terms of the sizing of detected defects. Moreover, an attempt was made to correlate the proportion and distribution of surface defects with the results of peel decohesion tests; but the low sensitivity of these mechanical tests made it difficult to establish a reliable link between the energy required for decohesion and the distribution and proportion of the surface defects. Now the implementation of acceptance criteria for defects – either surfacic or volumic - in welded assemblies requires the establishment of strong correlations between PAUT data and mechanical tests capable of representing long-term performances. But to date, an extremely limited number of relevant studies have been published in this field and the subject is still a matter of debate, as seen during the NDT workshop of the Plastic Pipes XVIII. Consequently GRTgaz Research and Innovation Center for Energy has launched a new campaign in 2016 focused on the volume defects, with the two-fold aim of confirming the accuracy of PAUT for the detection and sizing of volume-type defects implanted in a pipe- saddle electrowelded assembly on the one hand, and evaluating the harmfulness of volume defects on the mechanical resistance of assemblies through hydrostatic pressure testing on the other hand. For this purpose, four pit-shaped defects were hot-machined in the heating area of a 63 mm saddle at three different locations (outer, middle and inner crown). For a given configuration, the defects had four different heights in the saddle body. PAUT examination during the welding cycle allowed evaluating the changes in height of the defects. X-ray tomography analysis was used to complete the PAUT evaluation and to evaluate the final shape of the implanted defects. Hydrostatic pressure testing was then applied to the welded assemblies up to failure, with regard to the NF EN 1555 standard requirements. Finally peel tests were carried out in order to confirm the crack paths. This study reveals the good reliability level of PAUT in detecting and sizing the volume defects in the saddles on the one hand, and the fair correlation existing between PAUT and XRay Tomography as a complementary technique on the other hand. The hydrostatic pressure data do not reveal any detrimental influence of the defects – in terms of both location and size - on the mechanical resistance of the welded assemblies in these laboratory conditions. Duplicate tests should be made in order to confirm this point.

Related keywords : Polyethylene (PE); Phased Array Ultrasonic Testing (PAUT); Calibrated volume defects; Electro-welded assemblies; Acceptance criteria; X-Ray Tomography.
Please note that the whole article content is available on PPCA website onlySource : 2018 Las-Vegas


Related papers

LABORATORY DEVICE FOR CHECKING THE THERMAL ENERGY DELIVERED BY THE ELECTROFUSION FITTINGS

Author(s) : Dominique GUEUGNAUT, Adil BOUJLAL, Aymeric LOPITAUX, Bertrand SEVRE 2018 Las-Vegas

A special concept has been developed by GRTgaz Research and Innovation Center for Energy (RICE) for temperature mapping at the interface of an electrowelded assembly.The technical solution consists of a tubular piece in place of the real PE pipe, made of a non-weldable polymer with thermal parameters close to those of...

INVESTIGATIONS ON THE BEHAVIOR OF PE100 GRADES IN CONTACT WITH CHLORINE DIOXIDE

Author(s) : Herbert Terwyen, Roberto de Palo, Manuel Sanchez 2016 Berlin

New standards in Italy legally require that chlorine dioxide is used as a disinfectant in any new installation that treat water for human consumption. Chlorine dioxide is preferred to other disinfectants when surface water or water from rivers is used for drinking water supply and particularly Southern European...

RESEARCH PROGRAM FOR ASSESSING SEISMIC RISKS ON POLYETHYLENE GAS PIPELINES

Author(s) : Dominique GUEUGNAUT, Charles FERNANDEZ, Romuald BOUAFFRE, Bertrand SEVRE, Florent ANGELINI 2016 Berlin

Representative earthquake loadings have been reproduced in the ENGIE Lab-CRIGEN laboratories on three PE grades, including an excavated old PE63 pipe operated during more than 35 years. Dynamic loading does not alter the pipe residual performances for the three PE families tested, as shown by both the hydrostatic...

THE “NOTCHED CYLINDRICAL BARS UNDER CONSTANT LOAD TEST” (NCBT) FOR ASSESSING THE RESISTANCE TO CRACK INITIATION OF PE100 AND PE100 RC: DETERMINATION OF THE INITIATION TIME

Author(s) : Dominique GUEUGNAUT, Adil BOUJLAL, Aymeric LOPITAUX, Romuald BOUAFFRE 2016 Berlin

A specific methodology has been designed by ENGIE’ R&T Division to allow an accurate determination of the initiation (incubation) time of the NCBT data. This methodology is based on two different data processing procedures. The first data processing proceeds from searching the minimum of the second derivative of...

ULTRASONIC PHASED ARRAY INSPECTION OF POLYETHYLENE DAMAGED PIPES WITH CALIBRATED FAULTS

Author(s) : Dominique GUEUGNAUT, Florent ANGELINI, Romuald BOUAFFRE, Manuel TESSIER 2016 Berlin

A test campaign has been carried out by ENGIE Lab-CRIGEN in order to evaluate the acuity of the Phased Array Ultrasonic Technique (PAUT) for detecting and sizing calibrated defects implanted at the inner surface of a PE pipe.These calibrated defectshad four different geometries, called “V-shaped”, “half-V shaped...

The “Notched Cylindrical Bars Under Constant Load Test” (NCBT) as a Means to Assess the Resistance to Crack Initiation and to Slow Crack Growth of PE100 and PE100 RC

Author(s) : GUEUGNAUT Dominique, BOUJLAL Adil, BOUAFFRE Romuald, LOPITAUX Aymeric 2014 Chicago

The emergence of a new generation of PE100, named PE100 RC, with a significant enhanced Slow Crack Growth (SCG) resistance enlights the need for new testing methods in order to be able to test such resins in reasonable test durations. Consequently in the last five years some new tests have been designed to assess for...

Ultrasonic Phased Array Inspection of Polyethylene Pipelines & Fittings Used for Gas Distribution

Author(s) : GUEUGNAUT Dominique, ANGELINI Florent, BOUJLAL Adil, BOUAFFRE Romuald, SEVRE Bertrand, LOUET Patrick 2014 Chicago

Polyethylene (PE) is a widespread material for the manufacturing of gas and water distribution pipelines and a large number of PE electrofusion pipe joints can be found over the thousands of kilometres of PE pipeplines all over the world, thus generating an increasing interest in checking the quality of these joints....

3D FINITE ELEMENT SIMULATION OF ELECTROFUSION POLYETHYLENE JOINTS FOR GAS DISTRIBUTION

Author(s) : Chebbo Z., Boujlal A., Gueugnaut D., Vincent M., Tillier Y. 2012 Barcelona

(Electrofusion, Finite Element, Heat transfer, Interdiffusion, crystallisation and melting Kinetics, Micro-sampling) Electrofusion (EF) is widely used to join polyethylene (PE) components in the gas distribution networks. This paper provides experimental and 3D-finite element tool capable of reproducing the major...

IDENTIFICATION OF THE PE RESINS OF THE DISTRIBUTION NETWORKS BY MEANS OF THE DSC-SIS TECHNIQUE APPLIED ON MICRO-SAMPLING

Author(s) : Gueugnaut Dominique, Boujlal Adil, Rousselot Denise, Bouaffre Romuald 2012 Barcelona

(Polyethylene, SIS technique,Micro-sampling)The  use  of  polyethylene(PE) since  the  early  seventies  on  the  GDF  SUEZ’  distribution networks has lead to the coexistence of a very wide variety of PE resinswith significant differences  in  their  long  term  performances. Nevertheless,  in ...

THE CAPABILITY OF THE ULTRASONIC PHASED ARRAY TECHNIQUE FOR DETECTING AND MEASURING DEFECTS AT THE INNER SURFACE OF A POLYETHYLENE PIPE THROUGH AN OUTSIDE ANALYSIS

Author(s) : Gueugnaut Dominique 2012 Barcelona

(Polyethylene, Non destructive technique, Ultrasonic Phased Array, Slow Crack initiation time) Since a few years it has been proved that - among the available concepts - the Ultrasonic Phased-Array technique (PA UT) was one of the most promising candidate for Non Destructive and Non Intrusive analysis of PE and...

Members of the Association

BOREALISBOROUGEINEOS O&PIRPCKorea Petrochemical IND. Co., LTDLyondellBasellPetroChina Dushanzi Petrochemical CompanyPRIME POLYMERSABICSCG Chemicals & Thai PolyethyleneSinopecTASNEE
TOP